What about using something else than paper today ? Done.
I use a canvas mini tag by Canvas Corp Brands with Red Barn Glimmer mist by Tattered Angels over a Fadded dots stencil (Tim Holtz) as a base.I search in my stash and found some silver mesh ribbon and a cream lace. I sprayed the lace with Leap Frog Glimmer mist and Black Magic Glimmer mist, and the poinsettia (I Am Roses) with the Red Barn one.
The only paper I use was a sheet of the Santa's Journey 6x6 pad by 7Gypsies to cut holly leaves.
A silver chain with a charm (Santa's Journey collection), some silver fiber and a stamped sentiment complete the tag.
I wish you a holly jolly day !